Email Print

GOP in SC: First Analysis

Update [2007-5-16 11:35:12 by Ross Smith]: Travel to D.C. and then to NYC for this PDF Conference precludes more detailed analyis from me today and much of this week, but I will add to last night's analysis as follows:

1) Readers who follow our links to the conservative blogs will find that there is near unanimity on Rudy's having had a good night and a split on McCain and Romney that seems to have more to do with the commenter's prior positions on those two than with their debating. If nothing else, his attack on Ron Paul will get played over and over.

2) Even some of the DailyKos bloggers from the left praised Fox News for doing a much better job of moderating than did MSNBC. "Slam dunk case" there.

3) There is a debate at The Corner on torture. Let me just note that in my debate class, even the most conservative students find that once they research the subject they find the issue nearl undebatable -- the case against legitimzing torture is too powerful, morally and pragmatically.

4) Listen to the archive of our radio discussion by going to the blogtalkradio link at the button below. Then comment here. Thanks!

With the at 11:30 p.m. EDT blog radioshow coming up in just a few minutes, here are my initial reactions (I reserve the right to "flip flop" but will only do so if there is good reason!).

Winners:
Fox moderators.
McCain.
Giuiliani.
Huckabee.
The audience.

Losers:
Romney.
The rest of the lower tier.

Read more for a brief justification . . .

The moderators at Fox had MUCH better questions than did Chris Matthews of MSNBC, exposing the real differences on the issues among the candidates. The "24" episode at the end was a bit of a trainwreck, but kudos for trying.

McCain looked really comfortable tonight. He demonstrated leadership skill, stuck to the message he really believes, and took Romney down a notch. Since Giuliani is not a threat from his right, McCain's strategy and tactics were w good fit for the situation.

Giuliani. Abortion was not a real problem. His reply to Huckabee was sufficient. He achieved his campaign advisor's stated pre-debate goal of emphasizing terrorism and his NYC record.

Romney. The deeper he was probed on substance, the less there was to see. McCain piled on the moderator's theme of flip-floppery.

Huck: of the lower tier, he sounded reasonable, sincer, and competent as he did in California.

The rest of them. No gain is a loss. Brownback has bad jokes. Tancredo almost is one. Thompson missed a chance on the Iraq question. Hunter only knows military jargon. Ron Paul was almost booed by the audience. Gilmore looked lost.

< GOP in SC Liveblog | Dem Primary Debate Preview: New Hampshire in June >
 Display: